How Do Enhanced Yield Fixed Income Indexes Stack Up Vs. Active?

The research team at AQR Capital Management recently published a piece¹ that attempted to explain why actively managed fixed income funds were able to deliver higher information ratios against their benchmarks than U.S. large-cap equity managers. The conclusion? Active fixed income managers tended to be over-weight credit risk compared to their benchmarks. While hardly surprising, that is precisely the rationale we focused on more than two years ago when collaborating with Barclays to create the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Enhanced Yield Index (Enhanced Yield Index). In this piece, we examine how the WisdomTree Barclays Yield Enhanced U.S. Aggregate Bond Fund (AGGY), designed to track the Index, has stacked up against other active managers in this space.

Strategy Review

The Enhanced Yield Index uses the same investable universe as the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Index, but then seeks to maximize yield while adhering to a series of constraints to limit risk. The resulting portfolio will generally be over-weight credit risk and under-weight U.S. Treasuries. Throughout its history, it has increased yield by 50 to 75 basis points (bps) while keeping duration within one year of the benchmark. All else being equal, the higher the starting yield of a bond portfolio, the higher the expected returns. Therefore, by extracting higher yields from the investment-grade investable universe, returns should increase. By applying constraints, we are also attempting to be cognizant about keeping tracking error volatility to 0.35% per month.

Real-Time Performance

As we show in the chart below, while our historical research was instructive, what really matters is how the strategy performs in real time. Since mid-2015, credit spreads have generally tightened, and interest rate volatility has generally been low. Overall, this environment has been favorable for most flavors of active and passive fixed income. Since inception, AGGY has outperformed 91% of all funds in the Morningstar Intermediate-Term Bond Category.² Over the last year, it has outperformed 90% of all funds.³ Put another way, our approach has outperformed more than 815 active and passive managers in the core bond category. In our view, this continues to strengthen the case that it’s possible to enhance strategy returns by enhancing indexes versus relying on subjective portfolio manager discretion.